Is "Fighter" a Copy of "Top Gun"?
The Indian film industry has been a hub of creative and entertaining movies for decades. However, in recent years, there have been concerns raised about the originality of some films. One such film that has sparked debate is "Fighter" (2021), directed by Siddharth Anand. The film is an action-packed drama that revolves around the life of a fighter pilot, much like the iconic Hollywood film "Top Gun" (1986). The question on everyone’s mind is: Is "Fighter" a copy of "Top Gun"?
Similarities between the two films
Before we dive into the debate, let’s acknowledge the similarities between the two films. Both "Fighter" and "Top Gun" are action-packed dramas that revolve around the lives of fighter pilots. Both films feature charismatic leads, high-octane action sequences, and a dash of romance. The plots of both films also share some similarities, with the main characters facing challenges and overcoming obstacles to achieve their goals.
| Similarities | Fighter | Top Gun |
|---|---|---|
| Action-packed drama | ||
| Revolves around fighter pilots | ||
| Charismatic leads | Ranveer Singh | Tom Cruise |
| High-octane action sequences | ||
| Romance |
Differences between the two films
However, despite the similarities, there are several differences between the two films that set them apart. "Fighter" is an original story, created by Indian filmmakers, while "Top Gun" is a Hollywood classic based on a 1984 article by Dale Brown. The settings, characters, and plot of the two films are distinct, making it difficult to argue that "Fighter" is a direct copy of "Top Gun".
| Differences | Fighter | Top Gun |
|---|---|---|
| Story | Original story by Indian filmmakers | Based on 1984 article by Dale Brown |
| Setting | India | United States |
| Characters | Ranveer Singh as Captain Bhumi | Tom Cruise as Maverick |
| Plot | Focuses on Captain Bhumi’s journey | Focuses on Maverick’s rivalry with Iceman |
Creative liberties taken by the filmmakers
The filmmakers of "Fighter" have taken several creative liberties to differentiate their film from "Top Gun". For instance, the film’s protagonist, Captain Bhumi, is a more nuanced and complex character compared to Maverick from "Top Gun". The film also explores themes such as nationalism, duty, and sacrifice, which are not present in "Top Gun".
| Creative liberties | Fighter | Top Gun |
|---|---|---|
| Complex protagonist | Captain Bhumi | Maverick |
| Themes | Nationalism, duty, sacrifice | Friendship, rivalry |
| Storyline | Original plot with twists and turns | Straightforward plot with minimal twists |
Conclusion
In conclusion, while "Fighter" and "Top Gun" share some similarities, it is unfair to label "Fighter" as a copy of "Top Gun". The film’s original story, unique characters, and creative liberties taken by the filmmakers set it apart from the iconic Hollywood classic. The similarities between the two films can be attributed to the shared theme of action-packed drama and the universal appeal of fighter pilots. Ultimately, "Fighter" is a standalone film that offers a fresh take on the action genre.
Is "Fighter" a Copy of "Top Gun"?
No, "Fighter" is not a copy of "Top Gun". While the two films share some similarities, the differences in story, characters, and plot make it clear that "Fighter" is an original film. The creative liberties taken by the filmmakers and the unique themes explored in the film further differentiate it from the Hollywood classic.
