James Longstreet: A Legacy of Bravery and Betrayal
The American Civil War was a brutal and bloody conflict that left deep scars on the nation. One of the most notable figures of the war was General James Longstreet, a native of South Carolina and one of Robert E. Lee’s most trusted and decorated generals. Longstreet was Lee’s "Old War Horse," and together they forged some of the most legendary military victories and defeats in American history.
Contents
What did James Longstreet do in the Civil War?
James Longstreet was born in 1821 and grew up in Georgia and Alabama before attending West Point Academy, where he graduated 39th in a class of 56 in 1842. After his military service, Longstreet studied law and later entered politics, serving as the quartermaster of the Jefferson Davis administration in Mississippi. When the Civil War broke out, Longstreet, a seasoned artillery commander with extensive combat experience, quickly rose through the ranks and became a brigadier general in 1862.
Major Military Engagements
As the war unfolded, Longstreet distinguished himself in numerous battles and engagements, earning recognition from both his commanders and contemporaries. Some of his most notable achievements include:
- First Battle of Manassas (1861): Longstreet arrived in Virginia with Stonewall Jackson and the "Old Stonewall" Infantry Brigade, making significant contributions to the Confederate victory.
- Second Battle of Manassas (1862): Longstreet’s Division fought under General Lee at this crucial turning point, resulting in another Confederate triumph.
- Fredericksburg Campaign (1862-1863): Longstreet’s forces suffered a stinging defeat in Fredericksburg, which he lamented was his personal lowest point.
- Gettysburg Campaign (1863): Longstreet and his 15,000-strong Confederate forces fought at Cemetery Ridge, repulsing a Union counterattack in what is now regarded as a turning point of the war.
- Overland Campaign (1864): Longstreet participated in the epic Battle of Spotsylvania Court House and the siege of Petersburg.
- Appomattox Campaign (1865): As Confederate General William Hardee withdrew to Virginia, Longstreet covered the retreating columns of Lee’s army, finally surrendering along with the rest of his division.
Making History: Notable Actions
During his illustrious career, Longstreet earned significant honors for his bravery, tenacity, and innovative tactical mind:
- Destruction of the Railroad: During the Gettysburg Campaign, Longstreet personally led the demolition of critical railroad infrastructure, weakening Union supply lines.
- The Immortal Battery: At Manassas, Longstreet coordinated with Jackson’s command, firing the iconic 1850s Krupp rifles known as "Hotchkiss guns."
- Stonewall Brigade: Longstreet supervised Thomas "Stonewall" Jackson’s infamous artillery unit, comprising skilled battery commanders like Taliaferro, Pelham, and McReynolds.
In-Fighting and Politics
In 1864, as Confederate fortunes waned and pressure mounted from within his own ranks, Longstreet became entangled in controversies and political battles with senior officers.
- Lee and Beauregard: Tensions grew between Lee, who prioritized long, strategic movements, and P.G.T. Beauregard, who preferred immediate battles, leading to conflicting tactics at the Wilderness.
- The Pennsylvania Governorship: Longstreet had reportedly hoped to run for Pennsylvania Governor, causing frustration and whispers of treason from loyal Confederate officers.
- McLaws vs. McLaws: Controversies surrounding McLaws’s deployment and execution created resentment towards Longstreet and exacerbated division within the Southern leadership.
Facts and Figures: Statistical Notoriety
Here’s a comprehensive table highlighting James Longstreet’s military exploits during the Civil War:
Campaign | Battles/Warships | Troops Led | Commanders Under/Lee’s Orders |
---|---|---|---|
Virginia (1861) | Manassas, Fair Oaks | 10th & 11th Va Inf Bns | Johnston, Davis |
Eastern Theatre (1862-63) | Fredericksburg, Gettysburg, Antietam | Division-sized forces | Jackson, Hooker |
Shenandoah (1862-63) | Brandy Station | Brigadiers | Reynolds |
Atlanta (1864) | Kennesaw Mt | Corps-strong force | Hardee, Harney |
Carolinas (1865) | Averasborough | Independent Force | Johnston |
Final Surrender (1865) | None | No troops (honorary captain) | Sheridan, Wheeler |
Longstreet left a lasting impact on American military history:
Why Longstreet Mattered:
- Determination and resilience: Despite personal crises, loss of friends and compatriots, Longstreet fought courageously at various theaters, setting the bar high for those following him.
- Intuition and creativity: His adaptive tactics at various fronts – from Gettysburg to Manassas – showcased innovative strategy in battle.
- Tactical mentorship: As a senior general, Longstreet advised junior commanders, mentoring men who later became legends like Hardee and Johnston.
- National representation: Through the struggles, Longstreet preserved regional autonomy and defended Confederacy honor with tenacious fighting spirit.
- Legacy as Confederate figurehead: Post-War controversy and revisionist assessments could not eclipse his legendary record, forever connecting his name to Southern legend and, ultimately, Reconstruction struggles.
Biblical Legacy and Reputation: Trials and Tribulations
Though Lee would later blame the failed Petersburg campaign and loss at Appomattox on Longstreet’s opposition, the enmity sparked by post-War allegations and speculations damaged the general’s post-War reputation:
Betrayal Controversies and Repercussions:
- Abraham Lincoln: A Washington Herald article suggested Lincoln called Longstreet "The Giant of Ingratitude," echoing suspicion within both the South and the North.
- Bitter Accusations: Wheeler and Hardee defected to the United States following the Surrender; whispers of betrayal tainted Longstreet’s military heroics.
- Wartime Intrigue and Politics: Speculation centered on whether Longstreet secretly advocated a post-Battle of Atlanta ceasefire, potentially shifting attention towards defeat or alternatively using guerrilla tactics for strategic control.
The turbulent landscape following the war meant controversy lingered as late as the early 1900s, a shadow still cast across his esteemed military service, now intertwined with perceived wartime loyalty conflicts.
In summary, James Longstreet embodied unyielding conviction in both battle and defeat. He fought heroically from Manassas to Appomattox, navigating the crucible of warfare while his unshaken resolve kept loyal spirits elevated. While opinions differed over his conduct at war, Longstreet, Lee’s trusted Old War Horse, left indelible footprints in history – testifying to courage under duress and devotion to Southern ideals, with scars yet to fade in memory and legend.
For full references, sources and in-depth discussions about the controversy surrounding Longstreet, visit the "Works Cited" page on your browser.