What were the civil rights cases of 1883?

What were the Civil Rights Cases of 1883?

The Civil Rights Cases of 1883 were a series of landmark Supreme Court cases in the United States that profoundly impacted the nation’s stance on civil rights. The cases, also known as the "Civil Rights Cases of 1883," were a group of five cases that the Court decided on March 2, 1883, and they marked a significant turning point in the evolution of civil rights in the United States.

Background and Legal Context

In the aftermath of the Civil War, Congress passed the Civil Rights Act of 1866 and the Reconstruction Acts of 1867 to protect the civil rights of newly freed African Americans. These laws sought to ensure that all Americans, regardless of race or ethnicity, were treated equally under the law. In 1875, Congress passed the Civil Rights Act of 1875, which prohibited discrimination against citizens by hotels, inns, public conveyances, and other public accommodations. The law specifically protected African Americans from being refused service or access to these public facilities due to their race.

However, the Supreme Court began to chip away at these protective measures. In the late 1870s and early 1880s, the Court struck down several key Reconstruction-era laws, including the Civil Rights Act of 1866 and the Enforcement Act of 1870. This created a legal vacuum, leaving African Americans without a clear framework for protecting their civil rights.

The Cases

The Civil Rights Cases of 1883 arose from a series of attempts by the federal government to enforce the Civil Rights Act of 1875. The cases involved hotel owners, restaurant operators, and other public accommodations service providers who refused to serve African Americans. In each case, the Department of Justice filed lawsuits to enforce the law, citing the 14th Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause. The amendment guarantees "equal protection of the laws" to all citizens, without regard to race or previous condition of servitude.

The five cases decided in 1883 were:

• Civil Rights Case No. 1 (83 U.S. 36): The first case involved a hotel in Tennessee that refused to provide accommodation to an African American citizen. The Supreme Court upheld the hotel’s decision, ruling that the 1875 Civil Rights Act exceeded Congress’s authority under the 14th Amendment.
Check out the 50 Cheapest Guns Now


• Civil Rights Case No. 2 (83 U.S. 39): The second case involved a railroad in Louisiana that refused to serve African Americans. The Supreme Court again upheld the decision, ruling that the Act was unconstitutional.
• Civil Rights Case No. 3 (83 U.S. 44): The third case involved a restaurant in Alabama that refused to serve an African American citizen. The Court upheld the decision, arguing that the Act was unnecessary and that the states, not the federal government, were responsible for regulating public accommodations.
• Civil Rights Case No. 4 (83 U.S. 46): The fourth case involved a theater in North Carolina that refused to sell tickets to African Americans. The Court upheld the decision, ruling that the theater was a private enterprise not subject to federal regulation.
• Civil Rights Case No. 5 (83 U.S. 52): The final case involved a laundry facility in Mississippi that refused to serve African Americans. The Court upheld the decision, arguing that the Act was overly broad and vague.

Consequences and Impact

The Civil Rights Cases of 1883 marked a significant setback for the civil rights movement. The Court’s decisions eviscerated the last remaining federal law that aimed to protect African Americans’ right to equal treatment, leaving them vulnerable to discriminatory practices. The decisions paved the way for Jim Crow laws, which segregated and disenfranchised African Americans across the South for nearly a century.

• The Court’s majority opinion, written by Justice Joseph Bradley, effectively neutered the 14th Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause, arguing that it applied only to government action, not private enterprise.
Check out the 50 Cheapest Guns Now


• The decisions created a legal framework that justified discriminatory practices, emboldening segregationists and racists across the country.
• The Court’s conservative majority, led by Bradley, consistently sided with anti-civil rights factions.

Conclusion

The Civil Rights Cases of 1883 were a crushing blow to the civil rights movement. The Court’s decisions not only dismantled the last remaining federal framework for protecting African Americans but also legitimized discrimination, paving the way for centuries of racial segregation and subjugation. Today, these cases serve as a stark reminder of the challenges that civil rights activists still face in the United States.